Lon.TV "Broadcasters To Encrypt Emergency Messages with DRM":
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dViecB76yco
Lon.TV - Broadcasters To Encrypt Emergency Messages with DRM
Re: Lon.TV - Broadcasters To Encrypt Emergency Messages with DRM
i reached out to a member of the ATSC board about this issue, and they asked me to take a picture of the screen during the message to confirm if it came through. will your setup/instructions be able to provide that aside from just the data?
Re: Lon.TV - Broadcasters To Encrypt Emergency Messages with DRM
I don't understand this response - if a channel is blocked by DRM, why would I have it tuned in?
Am I expected to leave a black screen on my tv continuously in the hopes of being able to see an emergency alert?
Am I expected to leave a black screen on my tv continuously in the hopes of being able to see an emergency alert?
Re: Lon.TV - Broadcasters To Encrypt Emergency Messages with DRM
I am fortunate to live in the Houston market where the number of DRM channels is still at a minimum. I do all of my TV from Linux apps and so really once DRM becomes a thing, it's likely all of our live TV including news, weather and emergency notifications will never reach us. My wife and I are seniors and I am an active YouTuber (@ScottiBYTE) like you. We are home bound due to health issues and I honestly find this entire move for encrypting the "FREE" air waves to make no sense. Didn't the FCC mandate that local over the air broadcasts should and always be free at their inception?
I have a container running with the SiliconDust test for the Emergency Broadcast message upcoming. However, it makes no sense that in an emergency that I would tune to an encrypted channel and wait for an emergency broadcast. The practical nature of having a National Emergency Broadcast System is that all of the citizens are reachable in an emergency. If such announcements are to be behind a "paywall" for a cable service or now an over the air broadcast, then that kind of says that if you can afford it, then you will know about an emergency.
It's really hard to understand who is driving such legislation and allowing a business case to take precedence over public safety. I can see a time when TVs will no longer be sold with any type of tuner at all. The idea would then be that all TV consumption is TV over IP. The alternative for air wave reception would then have to be a Digital Tuner device like an HDHomeRun tuner. DRM appears to eliminate Digital tuner hardware as it exists today because specific hardware would be needed to handle live encryption.
Being an Open Source advocate, my key comment is to reference what happened to DVD encryption which was reverse engineered to meet a consumer requirement that was simply ignored by the industry. Given sufficient time, every attempt at restricting digital consumption has been met with a solution. Wouldn't it be nice if industry would be proactive rather than reactive to consumer needs?
Scott Thompson (@ScottiBYTE)
I have a container running with the SiliconDust test for the Emergency Broadcast message upcoming. However, it makes no sense that in an emergency that I would tune to an encrypted channel and wait for an emergency broadcast. The practical nature of having a National Emergency Broadcast System is that all of the citizens are reachable in an emergency. If such announcements are to be behind a "paywall" for a cable service or now an over the air broadcast, then that kind of says that if you can afford it, then you will know about an emergency.
It's really hard to understand who is driving such legislation and allowing a business case to take precedence over public safety. I can see a time when TVs will no longer be sold with any type of tuner at all. The idea would then be that all TV consumption is TV over IP. The alternative for air wave reception would then have to be a Digital Tuner device like an HDHomeRun tuner. DRM appears to eliminate Digital tuner hardware as it exists today because specific hardware would be needed to handle live encryption.
Being an Open Source advocate, my key comment is to reference what happened to DVD encryption which was reverse engineered to meet a consumer requirement that was simply ignored by the industry. Given sufficient time, every attempt at restricting digital consumption has been met with a solution. Wouldn't it be nice if industry would be proactive rather than reactive to consumer needs?
Scott Thompson (@ScottiBYTE)
Re: Lon.TV - Broadcasters To Encrypt Emergency Messages with DRM
I like to Post but no 3.0 Channnel here in Evansville .In
Re: Lon.TV - Broadcasters To Encrypt Emergency Messages with DRM
In the video, Lon promotes his survey: lon.tv/surveyeas
He will provide the response data to the FFC. Those participating in the test can help SD and all of us by providing real reports of how it went to keep forward momentum.
I realize there is another survey posted here in this forum for this topic, and they too will publish to the FCC as well. Pick the one you like and submit your results.
He will provide the response data to the FFC. Those participating in the test can help SD and all of us by providing real reports of how it went to keep forward momentum.
I realize there is another survey posted here in this forum for this topic, and they too will publish to the FCC as well. Pick the one you like and submit your results.
-
elvisimprsntr
- Posts: 38
- Joined: Wed Feb 08, 2017 5:24 pm
Re: Lon.TV - Broadcasters To Encrypt Emergency Messages with DRM
fixed linkpaulbates wrote: Mon Nov 16, 2026 9:26 am In the video, Lon promotes his survey: lon.tv/surveyeas
He will provide the response data to the FFC. Those participating in the test can help SD and all of us by providing real reports of how it went to keep forward momentum.
I realize there is another survey posted here in this forum for this topic, and they too will publish to the FCC as well. Pick the one you like and submit your results.
https://lon.tv/surveyeas
Re: Lon.TV - Broadcasters To Encrypt Emergency Messages with DRM
KHOU in Houston did not turn off DRM during the test.
Re: Lon.TV - Broadcasters To Encrypt Emergency Messages with DRM
I tuned in to the DRM channels and all were blacked out. the non-DRM channels showed the message.
pay-walled here in Baltimore, MD.
pay-walled here in Baltimore, MD.
Re: Lon.TV - Broadcasters To Encrypt Emergency Messages with DRM
Will us "volunteers" that ran the scraper app get any results posted on today's tests?
Re: Lon.TV - Broadcasters To Encrypt Emergency Messages with DRM
Yes... targeting Monday. There is a lot of data to go through.Cozz wrote: Tue Nov 17, 2026 1:56 pm Will us "volunteers" that ran the scraper app get any results posted on today's tests?