Feedback request - recorded filename extension

Help and support for HDHomeRun DVR and HDHomeRun software for Windows 10, Mac, Android, XBox, etc.
Post Reply
nickk
Silicondust
Posts: 15994
Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2004 9:39 am

Feedback request - recorded filename extension

Post by nickk »

We are considering changing the filename extension used for recordings from .mpg to .ts.

Option 1: no change. Recordings continue to be .mpg extension.

Option 2: new recordings to be .ts extension, old recordings with .mpg extension continue to work.

Option 3: new recordings to be .ts extension, and any time a valid recording with .mpg extension is detected it is renamed to .ts.

Complications:
1) Files with .ts extension will not be detected by an older version of the record engine so it won't be possible to go back.
2) If using Plex or similar to index HDHomeRun DVR recordings you may need to reindex.

Thoughts and feedback welcome...

signcarver
Expert
Posts: 9123
Joined: Wed Jan 24, 2007 1:04 am
Device ID: 131B34B7 13231F92 1070A18E 1073ED6F 15300C36

Re: Feedback request - recorded filename extension

Post by signcarver »

I'd allow both... there have been times that I need to rename to ts to bring in to some programs and many think .mpg isn't h.264 or hevc while ts makes it more clear that anything can be inside.

Ken.F
Posts: 2291
Joined: Fri Apr 05, 2013 9:20 am
Device ID: 1041A706, 1043EB32, 104BAD9E, 13168DC5, 1322A7AC
Location: West Rockhill, PA

Re: Feedback request - recorded filename extension

Post by Ken.F »

I'm OK with option 1 or 2. I would prefer to not have existing files changed. My comskip script deletes leftover .edl files in the HDHomeRun directory if a corresponding .mpg file can't be found. If the recording file names change the script will wipe out all of my comskip files.

demonrik
Posts: 1318
Joined: Mon May 04, 2015 10:03 am
Device ID: 10736454, 1073A35A, 1075C377

Re: Feedback request - recorded filename extension

Post by demonrik »

Not 3
No real preference to change the extension
Has been .mpg for so long - but .ts is more indicative of what the file is.

djp952
Posts: 1244
Joined: Wed Oct 01, 2008 8:46 pm
Device ID: 131EB7F7;131ED0E0
Location: Elkridge, MD USA

Re: Feedback request - recorded filename extension

Post by djp952 »

In order of preference: Option 1, Option 2, Option 3 (ironically enough)

Option 1: Although .mpg might not be as accurate of a file extension as .ts is for what is being recorded, I've never personally had any reason to rename one in order to use it with a third party application. Don't break what ain't broke?

Option 2: Compatibility is a good thing, gets you to where you want to be with less pain for others. I would think third party applications will still be tripped up if they aren't looking for .ts, but at least old recordings would work while the application(s) adapt to the change. Perhaps an opportunity for some third party applications to interrogate RECORD rather than scanning the file system.

Option 3: Not a fan of this one. Likely breaks anything that doesn't interrogate RECORD to get the file names and as you said, there is no going back without a mass manual rename. Third party applications that are looking for .mpg are kind of hosed with this one, the user would have to shut down RECORD and mass rename the files to get anything done, and once they start RECORD again they are back to square one.

Have you considered a phased approach, starting with Option 2 for a period of time before cutting over to Option 3 in the future? Give applications some time to adjust to where you want the product to go. Also seems like a great opportunity for SD to publish more formal third party development guidelines for accessing HDHomeRun RECORD. You could push application developers in the path of interrogating RECORD for the available files, or if interrogation is not possible you could document that if the filesystem is being scanned, the valid file extensions are .mpg and .ts, until some future date when they will all switch to .ts exclusively -- which shouldn't be a problem if everyone is ready for .ts by then :)

$0.02

Jackamus
Posts: 122
Joined: Thu Nov 10, 2016 3:33 pm
Device ID: 1316E070, 1323748C, 13253D8E

Re: Feedback request - recorded filename extension

Post by Jackamus »

Option 1: no change. Recordings continue to be .mpg extension.

Post Reply